Film Review
For a film that is brazenly chockfull of clichés and looks like a
poor man's attempt to emulate a Claude Chabrol thriller,
Je n'ai rien oublié is, if
nothing else, appropriately titled. Director Bruno Chiche's third
film is something of a let down after his previous amiable little comedy
Barnie et ses petites
contrariétés (2001) and quirky drama
Hell
(2006), hampered by serious shortcomings on both the writing and
directing fronts. The film is however just about redeemed by a
remarkable triumvirate of acting talent - Alexandra Maria Lara,
Françoise Fabian and Nathalie Baye - who provide a welcome
distraction from Chiche's stultifying direction and Gérard
Depardieu's unbearably phoney portrayal of an Alzheimer's
sufferer.
Based on Martin Suter's novel
Small
World,
Je n'ai rien
oublié ventures into some intriguing territory (the
inability for someone afflicted with memory loss to separate his
present and past recollections from his wild imaginings) but
Chiche's unwillingness to take too many risks prevents him from
doing much more than timidly rake over the surface of some
pretty well-trodden ground. Some parts of
the film are truly cringeworthy (Depardieu looks suspiciously as if he
was doing this for a lark - his acting is terrible) and you'll have some
difficulty convincing yourself that the dialogue was not concocted by a machine (one with the
processing power of a Sinclair ZX81). Mercifully, the three
leading actresses, and a suitably sinister Niels Arestrup, manage to
inject a few shots of genuine human feeling and menace into the
proceedings, although this barely manages to prevent the lumbering
beast of a film from collapsing under the weight of the clichés
it carries on its back.
Je
n'ai rien oublié looks as if it was made for television
and that is doubtless where it will end up, providing blessed relief
for insomniacs.
© James Travers 2011
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Next Bruno Chiche film:
Barnie et ses petites contrariétés (2001)
Film Synopsis
For many years, Conrad Lang has been living off the wealthy Senn
family, first through his childhood friendship with Thomas and then as
caretaker of their holiday home in Biarritz. It is an arrangement
that suits both Conrand and his rich benefactors. But when his
health starts to deteriorate, Conrad begins to relate his childhood
memories to Simone, the young wife of the heir to the Senn
estate. Conrad's recollections differ markedly from the family's
official history and Elvira, the family matriarch, appears inexplicably
threatened. It is as if Conrad, a harmless old buffoon, has the
means to destroy her. As Conrad and Simone develop a close
friendship, Elvira shows that she is far more dangerous than she
appears...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.