Film Review
Akira Kurosawa's
Seven Samurai (1954) was such a
hit when it arrived in America in the mid-1950s that an
American remake was a virtually certainty, particularly as the Japanese
film was itself inspired by earlier westerns. The
task of directing the remake fell to John Sturges, who had recently
made a number of impressive contributions to the western genre -
Escape from Fort Bravo (1953),
Gunfight at the O.K. Corral
(1957) and
Last Train from Gun Hill
(1959).
The Magnificent
Seven so impressed Kurosawa that he presented Sturges with a
samurai sword by way of gratitude.
As far as remakes go,
The
Magnificent Seven is an impressive beast and deserves its
classic status, although it doesn't quite match the narrative power and
sheer visual brilliance of Kurosawa's samurai masterpiece. Of the
westerns that John Sturges directed, this is arguably the one that has
the greatest visual impact, and the influence of John Ford can be felt
in many sequences, most notably the iconic long shots of the heroes
riding across a stunning Wild West landscape like avenging
angels. In tone and substance, the film has a great deal in
common with Sturges' previous
Bad Day at Black Rock (1955) -
both films involve maverick outsiders resolved (seemingly without
purpose) to defeat a local threat against ridiculous odds, and there is
a distinct anti-racist slant to both films (something which was very
rare in Hollywood at the time).
In narrative terms,
The Magnificent
Seven is a crude morality tale that pushes the myth of the
heroic gunslinger to the point of caricature. Its central flaw is
that, unlike the
Seven Samurai,
there is no clear motive for why the seven gunmen should come to the
aid of the villagers. Just what do they gain for putting their
lives on the line other than job satisfaction and a few paltry
dollars? Yet the film makes a virtue of this apparent weakness
and throws the question back into our faces. Just
why do the strong ever help the
weak, why do we care about those less fortunate than ourselves?
When Calvera asks Chris why he chooses to help the poor villagers, the
question is left unanswered - as it should be.
The worldwide success of
The
Magnificent Seven provided a significant career boost to many of
the actors who starred in it. At the time it was made, only Yul
Brynner could be considered a star. Steve McQueen, James Coburn,
Charles Bronson and Robert Vaughn were all on the cusp of stardom and
this film certainly did their careers no harm. The film also
provided the talented young German actor Horst Buchholz with his
international breakthrough and helped to establish Eli Wallach as one
of America's leading character actors. The only one of the leads
not to go on to better things was Brad Dexter, who fell into virtual
obscurity a few years after this film.
As you would expect with such a strong cast line-up, the performances
are several notches above what you would expect to find in your average
western. Particularly impressive are Brynner and Wallach, whose
gunman and bandit chief go way beyond the stock archetypes and reveal
far more complex personalities than the script would
suggest. Brynner's terse, black-clad sharpshooter is one of
the great icons of the classic western and the actor would have the
opportunity to reprise the role in the sequel
Return of the Seven (1966) and the
sci-fi classic
Westworld (1973).
McQueen and Coburn both have a solid presence, and whilst neither has
much in the way of dialogue, their characters come across as
well-defined and sympathetic. Much of the narrative burden falls
on the slim shoulders of Buchholz, who not only has to provide most of
the light relief but must also carry off a romantic subplot - all of
which he does admirably well. Bronson gets some of the
best lines and the most poignant scenes - he is at his best
not when firing a gun but when he sits down to explain the notion of
heroism to a group of easily excitable Mexican boys.
On a less positive note, Robert
Vaughn looks painfully out of place and fails to make much of his part,
whilst Brad Dexter does a very good impression of the invisible man for
much of the film.
One of the most enduring and influential of the classic westerns,
The Magnificent Seven inspired
three sequels -
Return of the Seven
(1966),
Guns of the Magnificent Seven
(1969) and
The Magnificent Seven
Ride! (1972) - although none of these is as well-regarded as the
original. The Steve Martin comedy
Three Amigos (1986) spoofs the film
outrageously. It also led to a TV series
The Magnificent Seven, which ran
from 1998 to 2000. Elmer Bernstein's Oscar-nominated score
provides one of the most memorable film themes of all time, an instant
nostalgia trip for anyone who grew up with the film when it was first
released or regularly repeated on television in the 1970s.
The Magnificent Seven may not be
the greatest of the classic westerns, but it is assuredly one of the
best-loved.
© James Travers 2011
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Next John Sturges film:
The Great Escape (1963)
Film Synopsis
When a Mexican village is raided by a party of bandits led by the
ruthless Calvera, its inhabitants have no choice but to hand over their
hard-earned harvest. Fearing that the bandits will drive them to
starvation, the village leaders take the advice of an old man and
decide to buy guns to ward of any further bandit raids. Arriving
in a border town, they meet a hardened gunfighter, Chris, who tells
them it would be cheaper to hire men than buy guns. Although the
villagers have little to offer Chris, the gunfighter finally agrees to
work for them and sets about recruiting a team of sharpshooters to help
him frighten off the bandits. Having found five other experienced
gunmen willing to fight alongside him, Chris leads these to the Mexican
village, trailed by Chico, a young hothead who is determined to prove
himself. The next time Calvera attacks the village, he is
repulsed by the hired gunslingers. A short while later, Chico
overhears Calvera planning to attack the village in force...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.