Film Review
At the time of its first release in 2015,
Un Français was a virtual
one off - a film made in France that confronts head-on a theme which,
for some reason, hardly any French filmmaker appears willing to deal
with in anything other than an off-hand, tangential or humorous vein,
namely racial hatred. Of course, the irony is that xenophobia (of
the ugliest kind) is now endemic in French society, no doubt fuelled by
concerns over mass immigration and the country's parlous economic state
following the financial crisis of 2008. It is the elephant in the
room that no one wants to talk about and whilst no one talks about it
support for France's far right political parties continues to
mushroom. Diastème's uncompromising film about a
Neo-Nazi's brutal redemption smashes its way through all this gutless
complacency like a bulldozer ram-raiding a posh Parisian department
store. If, in doing so, it smashes to bits the one taboo that has
no right to be it will have done France no end of good.
It is exactly twenty years since Mathieu Kassovitz's
La
Haine first blazed its way across cinemas in France, showing
life as it was in the 'quartiers sensibles' (deprived neighbours) of
the country's mixed race ghettos. It was a film that created a
stir because it presented a vision of France that people were unwilling
to accept or just didn't care to see, and Diastème's film
deserves to have a similar impact, even if it lacks the artistry and
coherence of Kassovitz's grim urban masterpiece. The film spans
thirty years in the life of an ordinary man living on the margins who
starts out as a ferocious Neo-Nazi but ends up rejecting racism as
fiercely as he first embraced it. In parallel, we see the growth
of the Front National from a fringe party in the early 1980s to the
major force it is today as France's third largest political party, its
popularity continuing to grow under the polished stewardship of the
über-charismatic Marine Le Pen. Anyone harbouring under the
illusion that the Far Right could never assume the reins of power in
France should recall the 2002 presidential election, when Jean-Marie Le
Pen saw off the socialist candidate and went head-to-head with Jacques
Chirac in the final ballot.
For his second feature (after the comparatively mundane comedy-drama
Le Bruit des gens autour (2008)),
Diastème takes his inspiration from a hard-hitting British
television play of the 1980s, Alan Clarke's
Made in Britain (1983). Tim Roth's
portrayal of a skinhead in this play strongly influenced those of the Neo-Nazi
characters in Diastème's film, in particular the central
protagonist played with astonishing conviction by Alban Lenoir.
Throughout the film, Lenoir's character Marco is in a permanent state
of revolt - first against the human filth (as he sees it) that are
polluting his fair and pleasant land (if we take the French national
anthem literally, it is the duty of every French citizen to water his
country's fields with the impure blood of outsiders); then against the
racial hatred that he has come to despise.
The rage first manifests itself in outbursts of horrifying
ultra-violence which take up much of the first third of the film and
make it an extremely uncomfortable viewing experience. The film
becomes more interesting and slightly more digestible when, prompted by
a few chance events, the fury turns inwards and Marco suddenly wakes up
to the folly of his blind racism. It is an implausible
transformation, which is not helped by a jumpy narrative marred by
overuse of ellipsis and the odd contrivance, but Lenoir's total
immersion performance is utterly convincing, providing not just a
harrowing study in one man's spiritual awakening but also a metaphor
for what must happen in France if it is to avoid either a complete
social breakdown or the nightmarish prospect of a Far Right government
- a total rejection of the racial intolerance that is polluting just
about every aspect of French life.
Un Français does not
dwell on the reasons for the central character's loathing of blacks,
browns and gays. It is presented as a given, the inevitable
result of his miserable upbringing in a slum district of the French
capital. Perhaps this is a flaw in the film, perhaps it is
intended to suggest that racism has no rational basis. What
matters is that Marco comes to realise that racial hatred is
fundamentally wrong and has sufficient moral fibre to take it on and
expunge it from his system, like a body organ rejecting a deadly
virus. It proves to be a depressingly lonely personal crusade, as
Marco's friends show no such signs of wanting to change their ways and
his wife is a die-hard xenophobe who has nothing but contempt for her
partner's change of faith. In this multicultural era, it's far
easier to be an Arab-hating, gay-bashing thug than a decent human being
capable of accepting the differences of others. This is the
dismal message that Diastème's revelatory film leaves us with,
although in it's main character's redemption it offers more than a
glimmer of hope.
© James Travers 2015
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Film Synopsis
Along with his skinhead cohorts Braguette, Grand-Guy and Marvin, Marco
likes nothing better than to beat up Arabs and put up posters
supporting the Far Right. Then, without him knowing why, his
intense loathing for 'the other' suddenly leaves him. For the
first time, he is repelled by the violence his Neo-Nazi friends dish
out on the streets of Paris, hurting and maiming people just because
their skin is of a different colour. How can he rid himself of
the violence, anger and stupidity that he has within himself?
Marco's slow and arduous process of becoming a decent human being has
only just begun...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.