Film Review
With a few notable exceptions - the lively comedy
L'Amant de Bornéo
(1942) and moody period drama
Le
Colonel Chabert (1943) - René Le Hénaff's directing
career was pretty undistinguished, and certainly not a patch on his career
as an editor, on such classics as
À nous la liberté
(1931) and
Le Quai des
brumes (1938).
Uniformes et grandes manoeuvres was the
last film he directed and it easily rates as his worst - a limp Fernandel
comedy that gallops along like a mad horse, without any semblance of logic
or structure. At least Le Hénaff's previous Fernandel offering
-
Le Mystère Saint-Val
(1945) - had something that vaguely resembled a plot to hold it together.
Uniformes et grandes manoeuvres is just a shambolic mess that merely
looks like a lazy compilation of earlier Fernandel films, strung together
without any thought or care whatsoever.
Once again, the horse-faced comedian is teamed up with Andrex, the less talented
performer who seemed to be perpetually cast as the libidinous carefree bachelor.
In Le Hénaff's swansong disaster, both Fernandel and Andrex are effortlessly
outclassed by Thérèse Dorny, whose eccentric aunt is the only
character we are allowed to warm to. The bevy of beauties that the
two lead actors end up juggling, looking like old lechers in a girl's finishing
school, leave no impression. Just when the silly recycled plot conceit
involving a playboy-cum-inventor trying to extort money from his aged relative
comes to a shuddering halt through lack of ideas the film suddenly goes off
the rails and becomes a tedious rehash of Fernandel's earlier military comedies
of the 1930s. There are a few laughs to be had but for the most part
the gags are ineptly over-egged and
Uniformes et grandes manoeuvres
ends up as an exercise in futility. Lacking commitment on just about
every front it just collapses under the weight of its ineptitude and impresses
as the most pointless and vacuous farce you can imagine. In common
with several Fernandel films of this period, it must have looked as if the
comic icon had definitely had his day.
© James Travers 2016
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Next René Le Hénaff film:
L'Amant de Bornéo (1942)
Film Synopsis
Luc, a doorman at the Miramar nightclub, knows too well the perils of returning
a mislaid object to its owner. He recalls the fateful day when playboy
André Duroc left his cigarette case behind. Being a thoughtful
and honest soul, Luc promptly telephoned Duroc and was surprised when the
reveller invited him to his apartment to pass himself off as a member of
the nobility in front of his aunt. It seems that Duroc is badly in
need of some cash for a business venture and his aunt is reluctant to hand
over the readies. With Luc's help, Duroc hopes to put his aunt in a
more amenable frame of mind. The interview goes off better than he
planned. The troublesome aunt is so taken with Luc that she insists
he spends a few days at her château in the country. Duroc shows
up in tow, accompanied by one of his girlfriends, whom he passes off as Luc's
sister. When the subterfuge is uncovered, Luc takes flight and ends
up being mistaken for a solider on manoeuvres, with disastrous consequences...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.