Film Review
Laurent Bouhnik's stylish, big budget adaptation of Stefan Zweig's celebrated novel has
great strengths, but also some obvious weaknesses. From a purely technical point
of view, the film is impressive - the acting, photography and design are on a par with
any quality French film made in recent years. The film is as
visually striking as Bouhnik's previous off-kilter prison drama
Zonzon (1998),
although somewhat gentler in tone. But as an engaging piece of drama,
the film falls way short of its intended mark. The time-shifting Proustian narrative
construction adds little to the central story and, if anything, feels like a consciously
arty device to compensate for an unsophisticated plot. The lack of focus makes it
hard to engage with any of the characters - there are in effect three stories being told
in parallel and none of them has any real depth or coherence. Despite these faults,
the film does somehow avoid falling into the abyss of pretentious self-indulgence, thanks
primarily to some impressive performances from such first rate actors as Agnès
Jaoui (the director of the hit comedy
Le Goût des autres (2000))
and Bérénice Bejo (Jean Dujardin's co-star in
The Artist (2011)).
There are some powerful sequences - notably Marie's first meeting with Anton in the casino -
but overall the film lacks focus and dramatic tension, although it is not without charm.
© James Travers 2007
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Next Laurent Bouhnik film:
L'Invité (2007)
Film Synopsis
As he faces up to his impending death, an elderly man named Louis returns
to the Côte d'azur, where he once lived a troubled adolescence.
In a casino, he meets Olivia, an attractive young woman who is full of vitality.
After a sudden bust-up with her boyfriend, Olivia develops a fondness for
Louis and stays with him as he recounts a story that was told to him, six
decades ago, by a certain Mrs Marie Collins-Brown. Marie and her sister-in-law
are living on the Riviera in the early 1900s when she meets a young Polish
man named Anton, a compulsive gambler. A widow in her thirties, Marie
is so moved by Anton's fatal addiction that she is prepared to do anything
she can to cure him of his love of gambling. Twenty years on, Marie
recalls this sad story to Louis, an adolescent who has turned against his
mother after she left him to go off with her lover...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.