Film Review
In the 1970s, Philippe Clair was one of a select band of mainstream
French film directors who, Midas-like, managed to turn the cinematic
equivalent of dog poo into 24-carat gold, or, putting it more
precisely, conned French cinemagoers in their millions into watching
some of the worst comedies every made. Like most of Clair's films
in this benighted decade
Comment se
faire réformer was a box office success, attracting an
audience of over two million, although it is no more than a recycled
mish-mash of ideas 'borrowed' from similar 'bidasse' (military service)
comedies that were all the rage in France in the '70s
-
Les Bidasses s'en vont en guerre (1974),
Soldat Duroc, ça va être ta fête (1975) -
assembled with no discernible talent in any department.
Admittedly, this was not the most politically correct of eras, but
Clair goes further than most in his reliance on bad jokes about
minorities, and doubtless today he would be judged such an extreme
racist, homophobe and misogynist that even the Front National would
turn down his application for membership. As serious a fault as
this is, this is not his film's biggest offence.
Comment se faire réformer is
simply a film that has no right to exist - it has no plot, no
originality, shows no skill or intelligence in any area, and seems to
have been thrown together in haste with less than no thought.
Richard Anconina made his screen debut as the stereotypical Jew in this
film (and has presumably tried to live it down ever since). If
you think this film is dire, wait until you've seen its 'sequel',
Les Réformés se portent bien (1978).
If bad taste and a penchant for asinine comedies were capital crimes,
Philippe Clair would have been guillotined within a week of either film
being released. As it was, in the 1970s, the French just could
not get enough of his style of humour.
© James Travers 2015
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Film Synopsis
Two rebellious young men are prepared to resort to any means possible
to escape their military service. Neither has any intention of
serving under his country's colours for the stipulatory whole year, so
as a last resort they decide to open fire on their superiors' tent
during a firing exercise...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.