Film Review
There is little doubt that 2011 has been a vintage year for French
cinema. In a year that saw ticket sales hit a 45-year high and
exhibited a diversity of film that most other countries (including the
United States) can but envy, the French film industry has never looked
healthier. And this in spite of a worldwide recession from which
France has been far from immune. Two months ago it seemed that
Dany Boon's lowbrow comedy
Rien à declarer was a
safe bet for the most successful French film of the year, with its
impressive audience of 8.2 million. No one expected the cinematic
juggernaut that was to come bounding over the horizon towards the year
end.
Intouchables was
to be the biggest surprise in a year full of surprises. It
smashed the 42-year long box office record previously set by the
wartime comedy
La Grande vadrouille (1966)
within just nine weeks of its first run in France and could yet
overtake Boon's mammoth 2008 hit
Bienvenue chez les Ch'tis to
become the most successful French film to date. It has already
sold 18 million tickets and is still playing to packed houses.
What makes the success of
Intouchables
most surprising is that it is far from being a conventional French
comedy. Indeed, it deals with a subject that could hardly be more
ill-suited for laughs.
The idea for the film first came to directors Olivier Nakache and Eric
Toledano in 2001 when they saw a documentary on French television which
recounted how the wealthy businessman and tetraplegic Philippe Pozzo di
Borgo overcame his extreme physical disability and was able to live a
full and active life as a direct result of his friendship with a black
carer. A decade on, having established themselves with three
popular mainstream comedies -
Je préfère qu'on reste amis
(2005),
Nos jours heureux (2006) and
Tellement proches (2009) -
Nakache and Toledano finally felt confident to make a film about Pozzo
di Borgo's remarkable story. The only thing that Pozzo di Borgo
insisted upon when the filmmakers sought the rights to his
autobiography
Le Second Souffle
was that they tell his story through the prism of comedy, and not
attempt to seek pity. Nakache and Toledano fulfilled that brief
admirably, and in doing so they delivered a film that is quite unlike
any other - uproariously funny one moment, genuinely poignant the next
- a film that is a testament not only to the durability of the human
spirit but also to the power of friendship. It also reminds us
that we should never allow ourselves to blinded by prejudice. The
film's title has a very subtle irony.
At first,
Intouchables does
just about everything it can to convince us that it is nothing more
than an irreverent buddy movie, lowbrow fare intended for the prime
time slot on the less respectable French television channels. It
begins with an elaborate set up for a not particularly funny joke whose
only reason to be is that it explains the film's title. (It is
not worth the wait.) First impressions can be very
deceptive. Once you get into it, the film acquires greater meaning
and proves to be something far more worthy than is first apparent - an
incisive commentary on how society regards the disabled and
disadvantaged. The two main characters in the film - Philippe and
Driss (superbly played by François Cluzet and Omar Sy, one of
the more successful French film double acts in recent years) - would
appear to have nothing in common. The former is a man of culture
and refinement who has lived a privileged and easy life, until the
paragliding accident which robbed him of his mobility and will to
live. Driss, his unlikely carer, comes from the other end of the
social spectrum, an unemployed, seemingly unemployable black youth who
lives in a pokey state-provided hovel in one of the grimmer areas of
Paris. The only thing that connects the two men
is that they both
appear to have no future. And yet something magical happens when
they meet. It is like one of those school science experiments
where you end up blowing half your face away after mixing the
seemingling innocuous contents of two test tubes. To say that
Philippe and Driss each enjoys a new lease of life as a result of their
encounter is understating it. What happens when their insular
little worlds collide is like a far-gone star suddenly going supernova
- they literally bring each other back from the dead.
Far from being merely a tame feel-good comedy (as some reviewers have
unfairly characterised it),
Intouchables
is an enriching piece of humanist cinema that forces us to confront some of the
deeper and nastier truths about ourselves. In particular, it
challenges our expectations (by dint of the subject matter and its
unorthodox treatment) and slyly plays on our propensity for taking
things at face value. Instead of plonking all and sundry into the
convenient time-honoured pigeonholes (as black, disabled, immigrant,
filthy rich, etc.) we should look for what marks them out as
individuals and celebrate diversity, not barren conformity. The
film's central message is simple but one that is effectively rendered:
we should never give up on someone just because he or she appears to
be a physical or social write-off, and that includes ourselves.
Although it may not have been intended as such,
Intouchables also provides a cogent
allegory on the importance of immigration in helping to revitalise
developed countries. Without a constant influx of new lifeblood,
these countries risk becoming stale and paralysed, both culturally and
economically. The happy outcome of Philippe's meeting with Driss
is one that boldly reasserts the worth of the cultural exchange that
flows from immigration.
Intouchables treads some
serious ground and offers some surprisingly profound insights, but it
does so in such a carefree, unselfconscious manner that this appears
almost to be accidental (and maybe it was, in part). The jokes
are liberally scattered and are of the kind that are likely to appeal
to a mainstream French audience - not particularly sophisticated but
irresistibly funny for the most part (although some are a little on the
sick side). The humour is what makes the film fun to watch but
that is not what stays with you afterwards. The reason why the
film is so memorable, and probably why it has struck such a chord with
French audiences in 2011/2, is because it tackles some sensitive and
important subjects (racial tolerance, acceptance of the disabled, etc.)
directly, without having to play the obvious emotional cards. It
shows that friendship can be as potent a catalyst for self-renewal as
romantic love, it reminds us that we should not rush to judge others,
but, most of all, it persuades us of the need to be more willing to
embrace the unknown and the unfamiliar, so that we may break free of
our cocoons and live a richer and more purposeful life. If any
film deserves to be the biggest French cinema hit ever,
this is probably it - an original upbeat comedy that makes us
take a long, hard look at ourselves, showing us
how things might be if
there were a little bit more tolerance and understanding in the world.
© James Travers 2012
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.