Film Review
Whilst the classic western has always had an enduring appeal for French
cinema audiences, France's own attempts at emulating the genre are
exceeding few and far between and, of the few French westerns that have
been made, virtually none is worth the price of the cinema
ticket. Guy Lefranc's
Fernand cow-boy (1956) manages
to be a fairly likeable spoof but Jean Bastia's
Dynamite
Jack (1960) is excruciatingly dull, despite the almost
surreal pairing of Fernandel with Adrienne Corri. The only French
westerns that can hold a candle to their American counterparts are the
animated adventures of Lucky Luke, represented by René
Goscinny's
Lucky Luke Daisy Town (1971)
and
La Ballade des Dalton
(1978).
Les Pétroleuses
(a.k.a.
The legend of Frenchie King)
is at the exact opposite of the quality spectrum, a ramshackle spoof
that isn't so much a western as a kinky male fantasy gone south, with a
butched-up Brigitte Bardot and turbo-feisty Claudia Cardinale proving
that the Wild West is definitely no place for a man, especially not
when it is deluged in clichés.
After watching Mel Brooks'
Blazing Saddles (1974) any
parody of the classic western is bound to appear trite and sterile, but
you don't have to see Brooks' film to appreciate just how awful
Les Pétroleuses is. If
the film was scripted there's precious little sign of it - it just
seems to be a chaotically cobbled together succession of lame comedy
situations that are performed and directed in a way that implies talent
had suddenly gone out of fashion. There are some who will
doubtless derive some pleasure from watching Brigitte Bardot play the
pistol-firing dominatrix for all it is worth, humiliating every male
she encounters as she claims the West as her own with her band of black
clad amazons, and her cat fight with Claudia Cardinale is a sight to
behold (probably the silliest fight scene ever to committed to
celluloid). Bardot's performance is so over-the-top that it makes
you wince, but after being exploited by film producers and directors
for two decades, we can forgive her this long-overdue two-fingered
salute to an industry she had come to despise. A woman's revenge
is never a pretty sight, even if she is wearing tight-fitting corsets
and a low-cut bra at the time.
As well as being (possibly) Bardot's worst film,
Les Pétroleuses has the
distinction of being the last film in which Valéry Inkijnoff
appeared, oddly cast as a Red Indian. After debuting in Vsevolod
Pudovkin's
Storm Over Asia (1928),
Inkijnoff became a star of French cinema in the 1930s, typecast for
most of his career as oriental and other exotic-looking villains.
Here he is completely wasted. Micheline Presle shows up briefly
(too briefly to do the film any good), and for want of a decent male
actor Michael J. Pollard is foisted on us, untiringly irritating as a
stock comedy sheriff of the kind who is so stupid he looks as if he
might garrotte himself every time he ties up his boot laces. The
rest of the cast don't even deserve a passing mention - in the
pursuance of mediocrity it's nice to see that no barrel bottom was left
unscraped.
Christian-Jaque was virtually at the end of his long career when he
directed this film, and this might explain why he shows no flair and
enthusiasm for the subject. Indeed, you wonder if he ever bothered
showing up on the set, judging by the asinine mess that somehow ended
up on the cinema screen. Although he receives no on-screen
credit, Guy Casaril also directed part of the film, presumably to the
same standard of his previous Bardot vehicle,
Les
Novices, where his work was so poor he ended up being
dismissed and replaced with Claude Chabrol (who then decided the film
was so bad that he refused to put his name to it).
It's clear that a large pile of French francs was thrown at the film
and in some departments - the set design, camerawork and scoring - the
production values are on a par with those of the better Italian
spaghetti westerns of the time. But everywhere else - the
writing, the directing, the acting - the efforts are at best
amateurish.
Les
Pétroleuses is sporadically funny in places but overall
it provokes more teeth grinding than laughter. Unless you have a
serious fetish about fading buxom beauties in cowboy boots and Stetsons
it's not great entertainment - in fact it's about as rewarding as
watching a glass of water evaporate. Let's face it - when it
comes to westerns, even comedy westerns, the French just haven't a clue.
© James Travers, Willems Henri 2015
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Next Christian-Jaque film:
Compartiment de dames seules (1934)