Film Review
The Algerian War has long been a taboo subject in France.
The war wasn't even recognised as such by the French state until 1999
and all attempts to represent it in cinema were vehemently opposed by
the military and the government for well over a decade after Algeria
gained independence in 1962.
Jean-Luc Godard's
Le
Petit soldat (1963) was banned and could not be shown in
France until the war had ended. Ten years later, director
René Vautier had to resort to a hunger strike to obtain a
distribution visa for his film
Avoir 20 ans dans les Aurès
(1972). When Yves Boisset, an established agent provocateur, set
about making a film about the Algerian conflict, it was inevitable that
the Powers That Be would do everything within their power to stop
him. And they almost succeeded.
Yves Boisset was a live wire and the French army had good reason to be
concerned about what he might reveal in his film. The director
had just made a film,
L'Attentat,
about the controversial Ben Barka affair, in which it was implied that
the French state actively colluded with Israel intelligence agents in
the abduction and killing of a prominent Moroccan politician.
Boisset's attempts to raise funding for his Algeria War exposé
were thwarted on three separate occasions, and once he had obtained the
financial wherewithal to make the film the military did everything
within its power to oppose him. Boisset was refused access to
barracks, pressure was put on costume suppliers not to loan him combat
uniforms (forcing him to make use of Belgian uniforms), and the
Algerian government had its arms twisted by France to forbid the film
from being shot in Algeria (it was instead filmed in Tunisia).
Once the location filming had been completed, some reels of film
mysteriously went missing (one just happened to contain a torture
scene), forcing the director to re-shoot several sequences.
Although the government censor allowed the film to be released
(probably through fear that an outright ban would merely serve
Boisset's case and raise the film's profile), several cuts were
insisted upon and it was issued with an over-16 certificate. Even
though the Algerian War was still a painful subject for the French
people,
R.A.S. proved to be a
huge commercial success and attracted 1.3 million spectators. As
expected, the film was ill-received in some quarters. Several
towns banned the film, whilst in others screenings were disrupted by
rightwing demonstrators and even grenade attacks. One of the most
provocative and controversial French films of the decade,
R.A.S. is very rarely screened on
French television and has so far not been released on DVD - an
indication perhaps that the old wounds have still yet to heal.
The film's title - an allusion to Robert Altman's
M.A.S.H. (1970) - is an acronym
for
Rien à signaler,
meaning
Nothing to report.
Based on firsthand experiences of Algerian War veterans, the film is a
shocking indictment of the methods employed by the French military in
its campaign of pacification in Algeria between 1954 and 1962. The
aptness of the title soon becomes apparent - if the French public had
known that the military had resorted to torture, rape and summary
execution to achieve its aims, support for the campaign would have
crumbled a lot faster than it did. Boisset has often been
criticised for resorting to shock tactics in his films and of having a
strong political bias. In
R.A.S.,
his most uncompromising film, his provocative approach has been
entirely vindicated and the film is now considered one of the most
authentic portrayals of the French side of the Algerian conflict.
Recent films like Steven Spielberg's
Saving Private Ryan (1998) have
practically inured us to the horrors of modern warfare, but whilst
R.A.S. is less viscerally shocking
than today's war films, it still manages to be a pretty gruelling
viewing experience. It is not a film that you will forget in a
hurry. Its first half focuses on the brutal indoctrination
('training' would be too grand a word) of a batch of
wet-behind-the-ears reservists into the ways of the
military. As they are driven to the limits of physical and
mental endurance by a sadistic adjutant with obvious psychopathic
tendencies, it is not surprising that some of them go completely off
the rails. Then, after this gentle softening up, come the real
shocks - a relentless catalogue of bestial atrocities intended to put
the Algerian people in their place. Watching this spectacle of
subjugation and humiliation is like being repeatedly beaten in the
face, and it is a struggle to get through it without being physically
sick. Florent Emilio Siri's more recent film on the Algerian War,
L'Ennemi intime (2007), is far
more graphic in its depiction of violence, but it feels tame compared
with what
R.A.S. presents,
mainly because Boisset employs a far more restrained, matter-of-fact
style of film reportage.
The absence of established actors in the cast adds to the film's
authentic, near-documentary feel. There may be no big guns in the
castlist but there is no shortage of acting talent, and many members of
the cast (Jacques Spiesser, Jacques Weber, Jean-François Balmer,
Claude Brosset and Roland Blanche) would go on to become very familiar
faces in French cinema. This is the film in which Jacques
Villeret made his screen debut, his amiable persona bringing a badly
needed dose of humanity to offset the crushing inhumanity of the film's
subject. What makes the film so effective is the way in which Boisset compels
us to identify with the three main characters, forcing us to see the atrocities
through their uncomprehending eyes, just as Lewis Milestone had done in
his anti-war film
All Quiet on the Western Front
(1930). It is not the violence that is so shocking, but rather
the total lack of moral awareness in the way the military conducts
its operations. War crimes are committed with blithe insouciance
and then routinely swept under the carpet by those who know they can
absolve themselves by intoning those three magic letters: R.A.S.
It has been fifty years since Algeria gained its hard-won independence,
but you sense that France still remains in denial over its last great
colonial adventure. Boisset's film, along with more recent
accounts of the war, provide not only a valuable historical testimony
but also play a part in the healing process, to help France come to
terms with what is still referred to as
la Guerre sans nom, the war without
a name.
© James Travers 2012
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Next Yves Boisset film:
Dupont-Lajoie (1975)