Film Review
When it was first performed in 1897, Arthur Schnitzler's play
Reigen provoked scandal with its
lurid eroticism. This appears to be the same reaction Roger Vadim
was hoping for with his 1964 adaptation of Schnitzler's play, which had
previously been made into a film,
La Ronde (1950), by the
esteemed German cineaste Max Ophüls. In his cleverly
tongue-in-cheek version, Ophüls handles the raunchier aspects of
the play with whimsical metaphor (the breakdown of a merry-go-round
representing impotency), whereas Vadim prefers the more full-frontal
approach. It is not hard to see which is the superior film.
By this stage in his career, Vadim had pretty well depleted his modest
stock of inspiration and good taste, and an endless supply of tacky
vulgarity was just about all he had left to play with. Had it
been made a few years earlier, when Vadim could at least turn in a
plausible imitation of a sensible artist, his
La Ronde might have approximated to
the stylish power of
Les Liaisons dangereuses
(1959), his one worthwhile film. By the mid-60s, Vadim was so far
past his best that his adaptation of Schnitzler's play was bound to be
a disappointment, but even those familiar with his late work will be
surprised by how bad it is. Despite being scripted by one of
France's greatest playwrights (Jean Anouilh) and photographed by French
cinema's finest cinematographer (Henri Decaë), Vadim's
La Ronde is a turgid spectacle of
vulgarity which appears to be incapable of distinguishing real art from
softcore porn.
It is hard to believe that a film which boasts the combined talents of
Jane Fonda, Maurice Ronet and Anna Karina (to name just three fine
actors in the impressive cast) should fail to impress so
spectacularly. It is reported that Vadim was so beguiled by Fonda
that he neglected every other member of the cast, and judging by the
performances it is easy to believe the truth of this. Only Fonda
shines in this tawdry monstrosity, but whilst she was able to salvage
Vadim's subsequent foray into bad taste -
Barbarella
(1968) - here she can only save the scenes she appears in.
Decaë's cinematography has a garish beauty that is occasionally
mesmerising, but this alone cannot make up for the sheer, staggering
vacuity of a film that cannot help collapsing under the weight of its
pretentious excesses. Max Ophüls's
La Ronde leaves the spectator in a
state of contented exhilaration. Vadim's version leaves you
wishing you could delete the last two hours from your life.
© James Travers 2015
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Next Roger Vadim film:
La Curée (1966)
Film Synopsis
So turns the wheel of love... In Paris, 1914, just before the outbreak
of WWI, a prostitute mistakes a handsome soldier she meets in the street
for a childhood acquaintance. For old time's sake, she offers her services
for free, and her lucky client leaves afterwards without the least sign of
gratitude. The same soldier, Georges, later encounters two pretty young
women at a ball. He flirts with one of them, Rose, before turning his
attention to the other. One Sunday, Rose, a chambermaid to a bourgeois
family, finds herself on the receiving end of the passionate declarations
of love of her employer's son, Alfred.
Later, Alfred is meeting in secret with a married woman, Sophie, who derives
a thrill from playing the part of the adulterous wife. Sophie's highly
respectable partner Henri professes to being the most faithful of husbands,
but he keeps to himself the fact that he has taken a young woman as his mistress.
The latter is delighted when she meets a writer who promises to make her
a famous actress. The same writer then spends a night with his former
mistress Maximilienne, who is now a great actress. The next day, this
star of the Parisian stage enjoys the company of a disillusioned young aristocrat,
who then meets up with the very prostitute who began this cycle of romantic
encounters...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.